In "Becoming Compassionately Numb," Benedict Carey suggests that, with the abundance of crises, we're experiencing fatigue--limiting joblessness benefits and disaster aid, cheering executions while booing a GLBT soldier (both of those at recent Republican debates! In fact, aren't all four of these from Republicans??), slow and minimal responses to Somalia, Darfur, Rwanda, etc. People in the help professions have long recognized such fatigue, especially when they see the same chronic, seemingly hopeless challenges. Interesting, he mentions the evolution of compassion as evolving to protect the household and clan; chimpanzees and monkeys also show compassion. Of course, we're more likely to respond to individuals in crises than larger entities, mainly because it is easier to relate to a single person than to an entire country, which is why non-profit pleas for compassion focus on single suffers to greater success. However, it has been found that first responders and doctors must actually silence their compassionate reactions to be effective in overwhelming circumstances; otherwise, they too would become numb and fatigued.
The second article, David Brooks's "The Limits of Empathy," discusses the actual disconnect between feelings of empathy and action. As Carey noted, Brooks's finds that empathizing with another doesn't always lead us to act compassionately, especially if there is a significant personal cost. Brooks's article focuses on what does: a sense of duty, not compassion. "People who actually perform pro-social action don’t only feel for those who are suffering, they feel compelled to act by a sense of duty. Their lives are structured by sacred codes." He continues,
Think of anybody you admire. They probably have some talent for fellow-feeling, but it is overshadowed by their sense of obligation to some religious, military, social or philosophic code. They would feel a sense of shame or guilt if they didn’t live up to the code. The code tells them when they deserve public admiration or dishonor. The code helps them evaluate other people’s feelings, not just share them. The code tells them that an adulterer or a drug dealer may feel ecstatic, but the proper response is still contempt.
This is why doctors, social workers, oncology nurses, and the other professions Carey mentions are able to respond--they have a professional code to which they are duty-bound that motivates them to act.
I have found that embracing the Unitarian Universalist principles or "code" has provided me with a clearer since of moral action than I had previously. As I've posted before (and here), it also allows me to communicate those rules to the kiddos more effectively and efficiently. We're always pointing back to the principals--"turn off the water because we protect the web of life" and "don't hit because we respect individuals." And while I couldn't explain this to my friends last week, it's why I take the kids to church, why I take myself. I don't doubt that they can teach their kids to be moral, upstanding, good people without church--I would be the last to say that religion makes a person good--but I find it frankly easier to do with a church, a code, and community support. As Brooks states,"The code isn’t just a set of rules. It’s a source of identity. It’s pursued with joy. It arouses the strongest emotions and attachments. Empathy is a sideshow. If you want to make the world a better place, help people debate, understand, reform, revere and enact their codes."Is it coincidence that we are becoming a less compassionate nation, if Carey is believed, as we have lost our connection to traditional religious codes? Or when those codes become perverted by fundamentalists who seek more to punish their neighbors than to love them? Karen Armstrong, author and TED recipient, espouses in her book, Twelve Steps to a Compassionate Life,that a true return to the Golden Rule, a version of which is found in all moral creeds and religious codes (including UU principal #1), would lead to a better world. With enough compassion for everyone.
No comments:
Post a Comment