"Where did you come from?" the neighbor boy asked Bud and Sis, as they ate lunch and I hovered inconspicuously, stirring something on the stove.
Oh, no. No discussions about sex and reproduction with a first grader and two kindergarteners at my house.
"Our mommy made us," came their reply. Whew. But I wasn't out of the woods yet.
"No, that's not true. My mommy didn't make me," the neighbor boy said to my kids, "God and Jesus did. They put me together with parts at church."
Okay, I think I'd rather talk about sex than God. My kids stared at him dumbfounded.
Thankfully, I know his mom and dad and their very liberal ideas on such matters (for instance, they didn't send him to CCD because they don't want him "infected" (their words) with Catholicism. And so I knew he wasn't getting this at home, but probably from the CCD kids at school), because then I said, "Well, not everyone believes that."
"Yes, they do. Because it's the truth."
"It's okay for you to believe that. And we respect your beliefs. But we believe something else."
"Well, you are the only one."
"No, we're not. We were at church this morning with a whole bunch of people who don't believe that."
And he stared at me as if I'd grown horns. Literally.
Sis kept insisting that she came from me, that plants come from seeds, that our brains and bodies evolved from monkeys, as the neighbor boy pressed his case. But my heart nearly stopped when Bud said that God had made his brain.
Now, as you know, I'm uncomfortable with God language, first because I don't actually believe in an omniscient, omnipresent, or omnipotent divinity and, second, because I am concerned about using the word "God" to refer to whatever natural, spiritual force I believe exists in the universe because it might be confused with the biblical God and all the theology that has been built up concerning him. But, I try to be open-minded and not reject out of hand my children's use of the term God, however they might understand it. But I'd be lying if I didn't have a knee-jerk reaction to Bud's statement.
I wished I had put more clearly what I do believe into words, both for the neighbor boy and for Sis and Bud, since I've read how important
positive affirmations can be in faith formation. But I don't have my God-and-science-and-mythology-as-metaphors-created-by-humans-to-understand-the-world-around-us speech boiled down to the elementary school level yet. And that's not positive, exactly; it still doesn't answer how I do think the world works, which, frankly, I believe is completely beyond our scope of understanding, hence the metaphors.
Anyway, the kids went round and round and round, getting nowhere and everywhere at the same time.
But when the boy asked, "Where do toys come from?" and I said, "Santa Claus," Mama kicked me.
Let's not puncture all the myths. Especially because I like that one.
On the bright side, the boy's parents, whom I called immediately after they all headed outside to play, got a good laugh at it all. And Mama, who had just sworn off church the night before because she just doesn't enjoy weekly socializing, said she'd go back, if only to
help our kids with answers to these kind of questions, no doubt the first of many.
Though, the questions are just as important, I think, as the answers.