I came to the discussion on
Motherlode late but am intrigued by the commotion about discipline, bribery, cash changing hands. It all sounded like a bad tv movie.
No, it's parenting.
Motherlode blogger Lisa Belkin had posted a snippet from another blogger (Amy O) on NYC Moms Blog that described how she had begun to give her kids a dollar a day if they behaved (it's more complicated than that but you can follow the link above to learn all the details). Fourteen dollars was a small amount to pay for peace, she rationalized. Apparently, Motherlode's commentors went nuts. I always enjoy the comments as much, if not more, than the posts on the NYTimes blogs (including Domestic Disturbances by Judith Warner). My two favorites, verbatim:
- Poor parenting skills that only the privileged can afford.— Carol
- So is the rest of the world is supposed to keep bribe money handy to keep Amy O.s misbehaved kids from acting up?— James
I didn't read all the comments but according to a later post by Belkin, several people mentioned Alfie Kohn's theories on parenting children, set forth in such books as Unconditional Parenting: Moving from Rewards and Punishments to Love and Reason and Punished by Rewards. He differentiates between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, stating that by focusing on external/extrinsic motivation such as sticker charts, rewards, and cash bribes, we are actually decreasing children's intrinsic motivation and hampering our own efforts to create lasting good behaviors (see the link above for a long transcription of his comments).
Personally, I don't yet have an opinion on rewards, charts, bribes, etc, but now have several vantage points from which to consider it, having only used a potty chart for a bit with ambiguous results. Apropos to us, this all comes at a time when Bud and Sis are obsessed with sticker charts. Oh, sure, when we had a potty chart with stickers, they weren't much interested. They didn't care much about stickers when they didn't want to pee on the potty and didn't care much about stickers when they did want to pee on the potty, but put stickers on the chart at other intervals. I guess that means they had intrinsic motivation. But you see, now Sid the Science Kid did a whole episode about charts and data as one of his science tools. And since the kiddos are obsessed with Sid (I like him too because he sings "I love my mom/my mom is cool" which they will repeat!), they now love charts. Yesterday, Bud insisted on making a chart to mark off when we take vitamins. He even drew in all the horizontal grid lines himself! Then he greatly enjoyed watching me check off a week's worth of days (not grasping the whole concept, he wanted me to check all the squares then and there). He's very protective of his chart, has put it on the refrigerator with a strong magnet, in a visible spot; then he likes to show it to people. Tonight, we made sticker charts . . . just to make sticker charts. Sis filled hers with a variety of Dora stickers (after I made the grid) and Bud carefully placed animals stickers in the grid he drew himself. They even had me make one. And then we hung them all up on the fridge.
I guess Alfie Kohn would be okay with these charts, though, because they don't represent any kind of reward or punishment system. They just are.
I know Sid the Science Kid would be proud.
I am.