Here are some things I've learned:
- FB is a lot like sitting at the popular kids' table in junior high. If you aren't on FB, you are missing out on social information that circulates there--who's sick, who broke an arm, who is on vacation, who is selling a piano--information that you otherwise might not get. Or you'd get it too late. Because everyone assumes you saw it on FB. You also are kept abreast of current cultural memes and jokes--"Hey Girl," Grumpy Cat, those e-cards, anything by George Takkei. I have found I like to be in the loop.
- People post a lot of personal information. I have, too. I realize, though, that there is no expectation of privacy and anything I post becomes public knowledge. Though, I kid myself that using the kiddos' initials and never tagging them in photos will protect them down the line.
- In many ways, people show their compassion and humanity--supporting cancer survivors, helping to look for lost puppies, sharing Autism updates--but I wonder if that's all we do? If we are lulled into a false sense of having done something through posting or liking on FB, we really haven't contributed much--and yes, I very much indict myself there. FB doesn't let us off the civic responsibility or social justice hook. Does it really matter if you "like" those things, especially when I have read how often those aren't real cancer survivors or "beautiful kids" just ad companies trolling for likes so they can sell them to other companies? Didn't you wonder why the source of the child with Down Syndrome was "Watch My Weight" or "Ads for Less?" But my FB newsfeed is a beautiful, calm, loving place full of supportive people who care about the issues I care about--but how are we creating that IRL? (That's "in real life.") I worry about the disconnect.
- While there are a lot of political posts, there is almost no real dialogue or conversation on issues. Except of course with the people who pretty much agree with you. Or really don't, at which point they drive you batty (and vice versa, I'm sure.) What can you expect from a "like" or sound-bite format? It is reassuring, though, to engage with and see the pet issues of my liberal friends online and shocking to find out which of my friends are not (there are even some Bush lovers in the mix! GASP. There are things I've learned on FB that I didn't want to know.)
- I wanted more give and take. I'm often without adult company for long stretches of time, especially not that Mama works late several days a week. I'm not a phone talker much of the time and few of my friends are emailers. I don't text, finding it worse than FB for meaningful exchanges--it's like a digital answering machine that demands constant attention. Anyway, I do like to exchange ideas based on current events and essays I'd read. So I started posting my links to FB, like I sometimes do here (which is funny, in a sad way, because my best correspondents are here on this blog and not on FB!!)--like op-eds on Trayvon Martin or Russian anti-LGBT policies and the Olympics including Stephen Fry's call for a boycott or something on Roman forts uncovered in Wales because of drought or discrimination against people with mental illness by medical doctors--and no one engages. Sometimes they don't even "like" it, or they post an agreement; rarely has it gone beyond that. Granted, I don't always post it with my own take, probably should, right from the get-go. I think I was looking for intellectual engagement; that was naive. But it compounded my isolation because I'd put these things out there and not hear back--I even posted that I was unplugging FB for awhile and no one commented. The opposite of sitting at the popular table, more like being a wallflower at the dance.
- I spent an incredible amount of time on FB, looking for said interaction, liking things and posting on people's status updates, even looking for neat things to include on my own status update. The interaction--the approval!--was there, sometimes, and really who doesn't like a lot of comments? But the time-reward ratio was skewed. And I realized that's a little desperate and lonely, even for FB.
My conclusions:
- I'm going to stay on FB. I like to be in the loop locally and culturally and this is the dominant and socially-acceptable way to do it in real time.
- I no longer like cancer survivors or beautiful children unless the source of the page is clearly "real" and not an ad company.
- I'll probably do even fewer posts with pictures of the kids.
- I've taken FB off my phone so I can't aimlessly check updates and post things. I can check my account 2-3 times a day when I'm on a "real" computer. That's more than enough to satisfy the above.
- I will look for other paths to intellectual engagement and personal interactions and not the superficial quick-fix of FB. I will try yet other ways to connect with people to discuss issues and events regularly. Maybe even in person! People still do that, right? (Of course, the irony of posting this on a blog doesn't escape me. Especially because my blog readers are the ones who email or call me up for coffee!! Maybe the answer is staring me in the face.)

