We've tried out two music classes now, both Music Together and Kindermusik, two internationally-known, music and play programs. The first, Music Together, encourages multi-age classes and parent modeling of activities with no stress on performance by the children, while Kindermusik is specifically geared to developmental age (so they say, but really, the developmental level of the age range of 3-5 year olds is extremely broad), with more large motor movement, imaginative dramatic play, and independence from parents, who do show up in the last 15 minutes. Both have songs (from diverse world music styles) and instruments, take-home CDs, and all sorts of parental reinforcement materials, along with not so subtle intimations that our children wouldn't develop properly either musically or intellectually without their classes.
And part of me is extremely critical: it's such overachieving, get-ahead, ambitious, suburban, middle class, yuppy parent stuff. And so unnecessary. Mozart didn't go to a structured music program, nor did Stephen Sondheim, I imagine. Just as Einstein didn't have Baby Einstein toys. (Not that I plan for my kids to be another Mozart and Einstein.) So what am I thinking? We haven't taken too many classes--one Gymboree session way back when, a few free, drop-in baby story and music sessions at the library and community center, and Chinese. I generally prefer and advocate casual learning through unstructured play, taking advantage of the teachable moments that present themselves to encourage exploration and imagination, and letting the children guide themselves (except of course, with Chinese, for which none of the above presents itself naturally. But we won't be taking anymore of that--the commute is killing us). Just hearing the other moms talk about the tennis lessons, music lessons, dance lessons, swim lessons etc., that their little tykes take made me want to pull my kids out of the brightly-lit, colorfully-carpeted, welcoming and safe, socks-only classroom right then and there.
I don't think my kids need these programs, even if they will learn some songs and continue to interact with their peer group and other adult authorities. We took the trial classes because they were free and because I was curious what we were missing, what was so great. Bud likes one and Sis likes the other. I like aspects of Music Together (the curriculum) and Kindermusik (the drop off) and have reservations about both (the multi-age class and forced quality of the activities, respectively), in addition to my concerns about classes for preschoolers in general, which I generally see as money-making and marketing hype, not without some educational value but not in any way a necessity for lifelong learning or happiness.
So why am I even contemplating signing them up for a class, much less considering signing them up for two different ones? No doubt I do have some of the highly contagious suburban fear that I'm letting the kids down or not preparing them properly if we don't do these. That the other kids will "get ahead." Which is, frankly, ridiculous, and not supported by anything I've read about early childhood development and extracurricular (considering that there is no curricula) activities. But I don't want September and 3 days in preschool a week to come as a systemic shock to kids with 3 months of all-mommy-all-the-time behind them. Not that I really ever pull off all-mommy-all-the-time--my babysitter will still be coming 6, if not 9, hours a week so I can do my workout and my work at the museum (more on the beginning of that wonderful adventure soon), as well as drink coffee and read magazines. As Belkin notes, "One of my dirty secrets as a mother of young children was that I didn’t really love playing with them," adding, "But I also stopped feeling that my role was to be either one of their cheerleaders, or one of their toys." I've come to the latter conclusion, even though I haven't ever exactly gotten to the mind-numbing feeling of the former (well, at least for long), if only because just when I might have become bored to death playing with them, they began to play with each other. Also, with two, I never played exclusively with either one for long. If there is something having twins isn't, it's boring. But even so, sometimes, it's nice to have somewhere to go, something else to do, someone else to do it--a little variety to an otherwise open summer, the responsibility on someone else to organize an activity an hour or so at a time. Even if it seems . . . superfluous.
I can understand signing them up for something I can't teach them--like karate or Chinese--but I feel like I can "teach" music, even if I've had no formal training, by exposing them to different musical styles, performances, instruments, just as we've done for three years (with success, as Bud loves music). But perhaps that is just vanity and I should leave it to the professionals Though, as a professional museum educator I really do believe that art, for example, is accessible to anyone with very little intervention--it's their choice how much interaction they need or want, what they want to get out of it. And, as my kids are 3, I just don't think music (or dance or sports or art) needs to be introduced through formal instruction, that they need to get a lot out of it besides some familiarity and enthusiasm, which I can do. In fact, a friend and I were considering organizing our own small art group for the summer (a smaller continuation of the one I ran last year)--couldn't we easily add music too?
But I'm still thinking on it. I had at first decided to do two classes (one is a week of camp, one is a weekly camp), then none. Now I don't know. For all these reasons. I think Mama and I have some talking to do. And there might be more blogging. Stay tuned. And feel free to weigh in . . .
No comments:
Post a Comment