Maybe I should call this blog "Mommy Healthy" these days, since I'm posting more on that than the kids. Well, this never was "just" a mommy blog . . . .
I've been thinking a lot about the American medical complex and big pharma recently. Very little of it positive. In my grumpiest, most cynical mood, I see doctors as shills to the drug companies who don't know enough about actual health and healing beyond which brand-name drug to prescribe for which problem or who are too scared of lawsuits or death of a patient (or who don't have the time or the interest) to prescribe anything besides the most invasive tests and treatments. For example, my previous GP loved tests--ultrasounds and ECGs--and medication; my current GP loves referrals to specialists for anything from athlete's foot to reflux. For that, my ENT prescribed Prilosec--at a dose 4 times the OTC dosage--and believes I'll be on it the rest of my life (he's been taking it for 10 years! And when I questioned effects, he laughed and said he'd die before I did from it). There was some talk of dietary changes (no tomatoes, no coffee/tea, no citrus, no full-fat diary, no greasy foods), but that didn't seem to really matter to him as long as I took the meds, even though the main problem with reflux is my discomfort without any real damage to my system (there my be vocal nodules eventually but that's about it). Lucky for the drug company that will profit, especially because insurance won't pay. Except I went to my naturopath/acupuncturist with the diagnosis and was given deglycerinated (I think that's it) licorice (DGL). And immediately, it's made a difference; much better than the Prilosec. I'm even off all of the Prilosec (mainly because I couldn't take it before tomorrow's injection because of its effects on platelets, according to the pharmacist). And I won't be going back. Of course, there are many doctors who won't even mention diet and lifestyle changes to patients, much less herbal treatments (do you think my ENT had even heard of DGLicorice?) before prescribing anti-inflammatories, antibiotics, pain killers, antihistamines, cholesterol drugs, blood pressure medication, and other meds. And I know that many doctors don't have any knowledge of alternative treatments, though an
article in the NYTimes recently indicates that many GPs are also starting to believe that their patients are overtreated (see also an
article on how vinegar can identify cervical cancer, an alternative way to identify it which is often much more reliable than pap smears!) I know that some of those doctor-patient conversations would not be easy, or even usually effective (and it's obviously taken a long time for certain conversations to sink in with me), but I believe as patients we have the right and responsibility to know what else we can or should do. (Proud of you, Vegan Pop!)
I've been exploring some of the alternatives to our American medical-pharmaceutical complex, investigating traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and other techniques in an attempt to find anything to help (like the computer game SuperBetter that I posted about yesterday!). I've got references to cranio-sacral therapists, hypnotherapists, a reiki practitioner, among others. And I must say, there are some . . . unusual . . . ideas out there. I stumbled onto something called EFT, or Emotional Freedom Technique. It's energy healing. Accomplished through tapping your fingers on your face and body while repeating phrases about your pain. As I understand it, it's based on TCM's theories of meridiens and
qi upon which acupuncture is based, but the non-medical founder of the technique has said that tapping yourself pretty much anywhere will work because there are meridiens everywhere. The tapping clears the emotional-electrical-energy blockages that cause pain (though EFT people will repeatedly point out that they don't claim to heal medical problems, just the emotions surrounding them). It's like acupuncture-lite, without the historical background and clinical trials. Skeptical yet? I'm learning all sorts of scientific terms--like the importance of falsifiability (mainly, that to be able to test something, it has to be able to be proven wrong; if any meridien spot works, you can't ever prove EFT wrong), the idea of regression to the mean (or that many people, with pain, anyway, will return to health without too much intervention), and the placebo effect. The
Skeptical Inquirer tore EFT to bits on these and other grounds.
It's actually not that far off from another theory that has a few more medical credentials, that of Dr. John Sarno of NYU, who identified (invented?)
TMS, or tension myotitis syndrome, and is supported by alternative medicine gurus Dr. Andrew Weil and Dr. Mehmet Oz. TMS is basically muscle inflammation caused by stress; in other words, it's all in your head. And the "all" is a lot: pain from herniated discs, plantar fascitis, scoiliosis (yes, I mention "my" three up front for a reason), fibromyalgia, TMJ, carpal-tunnel syndrome, pretty much any pain that has a musco-skeletal origin is TMS even if there is an injury! The cure? Listening to his lectures and doing his emotional work. Yep, you can clear back pain by processing, or just even acknowledging, your repressed emotions (mind you, you have to pay for the lectures and books). Because again, emotions (this time not electrical blockages but the brain reducing blood and thus oxygen flow to muscles, tendons, etc) cause pain. (In the
20/20 video Sarno disingenuously states that nothing has changed about the American back in the last 20 years that the nation has seen an uptick in back pain, which he correlates to people's brains choosing back pain instead of the less-trendy ulcers now--except he forgets that we're more obese and sedentary. One big change in the American back in 20 years? How about more sitting at the computer?? Interestingly he also admits that all of his patients--with whom he is successful in the 90% range!--are
pre-screened.). There's a psychoanalytic twist to this one: the emotional work delves into your relationships with your parents, childhood trauma, and the like. It's received a lot of press because several stars have been cured by Sarno--it's the Scientology of back pain theories. Though, even Sarno (proudly) acknowledges that 99.9% of medical doctors reject TMS.
That's not to say I don't believe there is a mind-body connection or that alternative theories aren't useful or helpful. I just don't think it's as simple as just saying that my back pain is only from my emotions. In fact, our ideal doctor would combine both Western and alternative medical theories . . . and we've found her. She's our pediatrician! (Is it coincidence or causality that she's Russian, with a background in both folk medicine and medical school?) She prescribes arnica and garlic mullen and humidifiers and cold air along with cortisone cream and amoxycilin. We even ask her for advice on our problems (she pointed me to acupuncture). Otherwise, I've long seen the value in breath work--I used to be able to lower my blood pressure and heart rate through breathing during numerous prenatal checks (I'd be hooked up to a monitor for 30 minutes and I'd work on my breathing to see the numbers change; yes, it was boring). I have also seen the value of Jon Kaba-Zinn's Mindfulness-Based Stress Reductions for the acceptance and reduction of pain. In fact, I just read Dr. Weil's
Spontaneous Healing and loved his support of less traditional (or, actually, more traditional!) treatment--many of which my naturopath had already given me--and his wariness of invasive American medical treatments (which, again, can be very valuable for certain conditions and issues). I'm going to try his
8 Weeks to Optimum Health, with its suggestions for supplements, dietary changes, spiritual work, etc.
But I will add this: I did some of the tapping last night, as part of a free "world pain relief summit" and also thought on Sarno's psychoanalytic approach, reiterating that I know that stress makes my back pain worse.
And I sat for a whole minute last night and this morning. That's about 56 seconds longer than I can usually tolerate.
Was it EFT or TMS? Or the cortisone shot I had last week? Or my continued use of supplements? Or weight loss? Or my hour of exercise everyday? Or regression to the mean after almost exactly 6 months from the second disc injury? Or even some early placebo effect from tomorrow's injection? Or even the dream I just had about being healed by my favorite physical therapists?
I don't know what it was (or how I can continue it). It was, in many ways, "spontaneous."
I just hope the healing continues.